I don’t rag on Pitchfork that much, I kinda get mad when people do, in fact. Yeah they are crazy and excitable, and they put out fewer brilliant reviews than they use to, but they get people geared up about new music and to play hipster backlash games with the kings of hipster backlash seems obvious and boring.
If I were to level a complaint it would be using the 5.4 to 6.9 level reviews as an insult. Tufnel-ian logic of this scale does piss me off; possibly because it used to be my job to devise and enforce this sort of thing and their editor are being lazy and dishonest. You want to write a dismissive, even mean review, do it and slap a 3 on it. But I guess what makes people mad about lots of pitchfork’s writing is it only has two gears and between rant and rave there is nothing. Rock critics are bad at writing about 3.5 star albums, which is weird because having something to say about average records seems like it would be most of their job since most records are in fact “average.â€
I’ve been sitting on “At War With the Mystics†for more than a month so reading over the reviews that have come out, none of which seem to have much do to with the album I’ve already had a chance to digest. It is not “Soft Bulletin†or “Cloud Taste Metallic,†neither was “Pink Robots†(which critics seem to suddenly love? Somebody called it a breakthrough. I have no recollection of this. I think what they mean is Wayne has gotten lots of ink since it came out).
Ever since Wife of the Future! bought me “Cloud Taste Metallic†for my birthday when we were first going out, I’ve adored this band so a pretty good record is likely to sound great to me, but I think it’s more than that. The songs aren’t that strong, but that’s not the point of the Lips. Think of “Spiderbite Song†or “Kim’s Watermelon Gun.†These are not strongly written songs in any traditional sense. So people saying the songs aren’t as strong (possibly true) don’t get it. Same for saying the lyrics are big and ham-fisted sentiments, cause that’s what Wayne does. I think the ablum’s welding of celeb-obsessed american values with our idiots-abroad forgein policy is brillant and yet it always seems like Wayne is singing about himself as much as he is Brintey and Bush. God that’s amazing.
I don’t write record reviews anymore (no tears, please), so I’ll spare you any further analysis. I just like this album in the purest sense: I enjoy when it’s on. Thanks to the fearless freaks.